preemptively putting NSFW on this.

  • an uprising in a ghetto against a superior oppressive force
  • the ghetto destroyed in response, thousands arrested, deported, killed
  • the blame somehow falls on the people being oppressed

You don’t have to dig hard to find contemporary people suggesting the Warsaw Ghetto uprising was a mistake and lead to innocent lives being lost, liberals and their proper processes, and civility, it never changes.

guess they should have voted harder. /s

33 points

You don’t have to dig hard to find contemporary people suggesting the Warsaw uprising was a mistake and lead to innocent lives being lost

Warsaw Uprising in 1944 was a mistake and crime against the people. Warsaw Ghetto Uprising in 1943 was the last stand of people being exterminated and deserve only support.

permalink
report
reply
13 points

Thank you for the correction

permalink
report
parent
reply

Could you clarify why 1944 was a mistake for the ignorant Americans?

permalink
report
parent
reply
14 points
*

I will start with the quote from anticommunist Polish general Anders: “Uprising was aimed militarily against Germans, politically against Soviets and really against Poles” because he nailed it.

So, it was part of the operation “Burza”, a large scale uprising coordinated in entire country by Home Army. Plan was to time it between withdrawing Germans and advancing Soviets, so to present the latter ones with already organised bourgeoise Poland structures (so a pipe drream even if successful). Home Army of course failed, they only known how to do nothing, and so the operation was launched in but few places and whenever it succeeded the effect was zero because Soviets just nodded their heads, disarmed the HA and moved further.

Now even that was only possible because Soviets were doing operation Bagration, the biggest military offensive in history up to date which completely broke the back of Wehrmacht and send them fleeing west in may places faster than the Soviets could advance. But that operation ended before taking few strategic and strongly defended places like Warsaw, Kraków and East Prussia. Soviet armies stopped to replenish losses and supplies and prepare for the next offensive. They were in no condition to assault major city, which was defended by river, and fortified and manned by numerous veteran German units of Wehrmacht and SS (including some of the worst butchers like RONA and Dirlewanger Brigade, all commanded by known mass murderer Erich von dem Bach-Zelewski).

So in that conditions, command of Home Army, with general “Bór” Komorowski, without orders from his government and against all recommendations started uprising in Warsaw, in which insurgents would be horribly undermanned and underarmed. And it ended with one of the biggest singular massacres of WW2, comparable to Rape of Nankin.

So, back to Anders and his quote, uprising was aimed:

  • Militarily against Germans, because obviously they fought Germans
  • Politically against Soviets, and this was the crucial point, with how Soviets were breaking Germans, entire operation and uprising was needless, hard to tell how it would happen in hte next offensive, but even hardest city fights in Gdańsk and Wrocław didn’t ended with even fraction of the civilian victims. No, it was all because the fucking landowners (Komorowski and a lot of higher HA officers were from aristocratic families) pipe dream and anticommunism, even Ustashe sympathiser like Anders bashed them for that.
  • Really against Poles. They just knowingly went with insufficient numbers and arms and thrown the capital with all its people at the mercy of nazi butchers which already were known for having the blood of millions on their hands - and it’s not generalisation, those very exact people who were garrisoning Warsaw.
permalink
report
parent
reply
6 points

thank you for explaining this

permalink
report
parent
reply

Much appreciated comrade, Wikipedia was unhelpful on this one

permalink
report
parent
reply
8 points

The timing was the mistake, the Polish Home Army started the uprising in August of '44, but the Red Army wasn’t ready to assault the city until January of '45. The Nazis basically tried to kill everyone in the city in retaliation.

permalink
report
parent
reply
25 points

That’s not nice that he is throwing that stone at that armoured vehicle! He could hurt somebody!

permalink
report
reply
18 points

Ghetto uprising? Hell fucking yeah!!!

Warsaw uprising? Biggest “shit your pants” moment in Polish history. And that’s speaking volumes, because most of our history is sitting pants.

permalink
report
reply

Still the difference is that Nazis were actively closing in on the prisoners of the Warsaw Ghetto, their extermination being the end goal that was already being achieved by starvation and random executions.

Gaza was several bustling cities, scarcity was definitely a thing but not to the point of starvation or malnutrition. The comparison is kind of disingenuous.

permalink
report
reply