I think there’s a lot of cultural motivation to be some kind of great person - be it because of the great man theory of history or the economic glorification of the captains of industry. However, as communists, our theories of history and economics don’t have any love lost for this analysis of the world. We recognize that without labor, not a single gear would turn. So, in my mind, success as a society doesn’t rely on the prophetic vision of someone unbound by the constraints of societal pressures, but by iterative improvements and experiments put forward by groups of people who could stand to be liberated from under the economic heel of serving treats and proliferating the MIC. In this paradigm, the person who does push forward the big discovery/gadget is congratulated and venerated, but the cultural zeitgeist shouldn’t be centered around that moment of discovery, but instead around highlighting the group and their efforts. Think of watching a Summoning Salt video instead of just the WR speedrun. If I can characterize my desire as wanting to be part of a culture that celebrates the collaborative more than wanting to be exalted as the person who accomplishes something, I can say that I don’t “lack motivation” because I don’t yearn to be celebrated.

I also struggle to see myself in chosen ones - I don’t write the MCs of my novels as inherently special, but rather people who have to rise to the occasion. I hear that media that depicts hordes of zombies (post-apocalyptic has never resonated with me) springs from the same core philosophy. I would much rather hear about someone who is weird because they had to panic and push through a crowd of normal people than someone who is normal who had to run their truck through a horde of zombies. When I think of what I want for myself, the conversation is never to cultivate what makes me special to live up to my potential, it’s always about doing something cool because the opportunity exists for those who would take it.

For example, with my black belt coming up in BJJ (in likely <year), I find a lot of joy in reflecting about how I took detours to learn about striking, wrestling, and judo while I’ve never had a genuine interest in my tournament results which have, as a result, been lackluster. For me, I grew up hearing people say that nobody’s cut from a different cloth and how “you’re a fucking sick (oops, can’t show that word on a Christian forum) if you want to be.” I went into BJJ because I wanted to believe that anyone could walk in off the street and, with the proper attitude, opportunity, will, and work become a black belt. I don’t know that it ever crossed my mind that among the public, I was specially engineered to get that belt because of some characteristic about myself. On the contrary, my enormous gag reflex, gentle demeanor, and sensitive skin would imply that I am particularly imperfect for BJJ. Sometimes it’s hard to go into a group of practicing MMA athletes as a weekly manga reader with no competitive ambition and believe “yep, I can hang with you shirtless people with tattoos and muscles!” even if I was invited by the coach. I think in my darkest moments I worried that inherent characteristics about myself made me too bad of a person to be able to accomplish the goal or that my accomplishments would be given out of pity. Even then, when it came to digging myself out of that hole, the act of showing up and being part of that community and touching grass mat helped bring me out of that funk when people showed me love instead of hating me for being me.

So, I guess sometimes I feel like I’m missing some fire or edge because I’m not striving to stand out. I do have accomplishments that stand out - I don’t like to list them in public because it feels boastful. But if we just look at BJJ - while it’s hard to get accurate data, a safe assumption is that <1% of people who walk in the door to do BJJ make it to brown belt. If the exclusivity were the goal, I feel like I should feel some other emotion about it. That maybe I should lean into it and make it into some complex about what a precise and superior fighter I am. I earnestly, when I’m being honest and sincere, don’t toil in the hopes of being more than someone else. Deep down in there I’m hoping that an attractive person I’m attracted to goes “oh you really like that thing that I like too! Let’s talk about it for hours” and magically I like talking to them for hours. Likewise, being really helpful and working on my own terms has 1,000,000x more resonance to me than being really rich (marble countertops, consuming luxury slop, having exclusive seating/priority, etc.). But with a resume of cool shit that I’ve done it’s like shouldn’t I want to pursue something until it’s amazing? Shouldn’t I be one track minded towards a goal? I seem to be floating listlessly and a goal might shake that up. Am I just coping?

Do you feel the same way? Without great man theory, imperial core chauvinism, and unenlightened non-liberating education do you still strive to be special and stand out? Do you want to be outstanding - the person who finally discovers and invents the thing? Do you have any guidance for me?

6 points
*

However, as communists, our theories of history and economics don’t have any love lost for this analysis of the world.

Quite a lot of communist leaders have seen themselves are great men whose theories are superior than their contemporaries/predecessors.

Do you want to be outstanding - the person who finally discovers and invents the thing?

I want to be outstanding enough to find a girlfriend and own a house and draw competently.

Pursue your dreams and goals whether it’s to learn everything or learn one thing to be the best at. Just don’t fall into Whiplash mode and abuse yourself and get abused by others who have the same vision.

Sometimes it’s hard to go into a group of practicing MMA athletes as a weekly manga reader with no competitive ambition and believe “yep, I can hang with you shirtless people with tattoos and muscles!” even if I was invited by the coach.

This happens to me when discussing most things with people. I have enough interest in something to dabble in it or do my job, but I don’t care enough about any of it to have sustained conversations even if I know what someone’s talking about or am genuinely interested. Like TV shows, guns, books, movies, anime, electronics, networking, programming, Linux, etc.

When I think of what I want for myself, the conversation is never to cultivate what makes me special to live up to my potential, it’s always about doing something cool because the opportunity exists for those who would take it.

Well, why does it need to be mutually exclusive? Not everyone has the potential to fully take advantage of an opportunity. Sometimes doing something and succeeding is what makes you special.

I guess I’m not being very helpful and just rambling because I have a different mindset. I’ve given up hope on my desire to be anything unique or special after entering college. I realized everyone else is smarter and better at whatever I wanted to do, so I no longer see a point in striving for any of that. I just strive to do something until it’s over.

permalink
report
reply

I guess I’m not being very helpful and just rambling because I have a different mindset. I’ve given up hope on my desire to be anything unique or special after entering college. I realized everyone else is smarter and better at whatever I wanted to do, so I no longer see a point in striving for any of that. I just strive to do something until it’s over.

I’ve made a lot of my philosophy by looking at people who are exceptional to me and seeing them look at their particular field of expertise. When they go “goddamn, I’m good, but I couldn’t put in as much as THAT person.” A preponderance of moments like that have highlighted to me the single path to mastery is that one track mindedness that keeps you in the “gym” eat, sleep, breathing the thing that you like. When I ask myself whether I want to live like that, I feel confident that I don’t. I think too many things are cool to forsake them for greatness in a particular pursuit.

permalink
report
parent
reply

When I ask myself whether I want to live like that, I feel confident that I don’t. I think too many things are cool to forsake them for greatness in a particular pursuit.

It honestly looks a little empty, too, at least to me. Maybe it’s so incomprehensible to me because I’m just a wildly different kind of person, but I have a hard time imagining how that single focus could fill every nook and cranny of my heart.

permalink
report
parent
reply
6 points
*

I want to be good at what I do, to exercise my talents and make stuff. In that sense I suppose I want to do special things, because anything I do is the unique confluence of my entire life. But I don’t care about getting fame or glory or riches out of it, I care about satisfying my own curiosity and creativity, and anyone who helps along the way deserves credit too because they were part of that confluence.

But I also want everyone freed up to be able to exercise their own talents and do cool shit too, so in that sense I don’t want what I do to be particularly special. I’m unfathomably lucky in a lot of ways and I hate that so many other cool people never really get a shot because of being born on the wrong side of a fucking map line or whatever.

permalink
report
reply

I’ve always said my primary talent/blessings is luck and the rest is secondary to it. I take away from this that the definitions I use for special and the metrics I use to measure it can be arbitrary. Not everything is a 100m dash or a UFC fight - or a competition to be the best, frankly. That’s worth sparing a thought for

permalink
report
parent
reply
14 points

i have a non sexual praise kink and want to be told how great I am all the time, it’s why I made black bean cakes today instead of using frozen patties even though only one person said they were really good after I made him try them u_u

anyway that’s just me though

permalink
report
reply

Only one person? You probably made that person’s day. That’s a W

permalink
report
parent
reply
10 points
*

I don’t need to be special. I don’t strive to be world-ranked in anything. I’m totally fine with being good enough in my fields. With that said, there are things I want to do and create, but I mostly do these things for myself. For example, I create art for myself. It’s cool, even great, if others like it, but my drive isn’t to be some beloved or respected person.

I just want to do things and create things that I think are cool. If others enjoy them as well, that’s a really nice bonus, but it’s not my main goal.

TLDR I just want to make cool shit. Thats it. Thats my goal

permalink
report
reply

I enjoy being around people with your attitude. I lack some of that creative spark sometimes. I have one artistic pursuit and it’s writing. People who create, build, dream, and inspire make me happy. I don’t dream, dream; I daydream.

permalink
report
parent
reply
10 points

Trust me, it’s not all it’s cracked up to be

permalink
report
reply

This is so mysterious, like what if LeBron James just responded to my thread???

permalink
report
parent
reply

chat

!chat@hexbear.net

Create post

Chat is a text only community for casual conversation, please keep shitposting to the absolute minimum. This is intended to be a separate space from c/chapotraphouse or the daily megathread. Chat does this by being a long-form community where topics will remain from day to day unlike the megathread, and it is distinct from c/chapotraphouse in that we ask you to engage in this community in a genuine way. Please keep shitposting, bits, and irony to a minimum.

As with all communities posts need to abide by the code of conduct, additionally moderators will remove any posts or comments deemed to be inappropriate.

Thank you and happy chatting!

Community stats

  • 1.5K

    Monthly active users

  • 3.2K

    Posts

  • 56K

    Comments