You can’t CMV. It’s quite clearly an anthem sung from the perspective of the revolutionaries amidst their struggles.

Let us examine the lyrics.

*On a cold winter morning

In the time before the light

In flames of Death’s eternal reign

We ride towards the fight

When the darkness has fallen down

And the times are tough, alright

The sound of evil laughter falls

Around the world tonight*

Clearly the stage is being set here - the communist forces have chosen to begin their revolution in the winter. The sound of evil laughter is a stand in for capitalism here. The “time before the light” is the pre-socialist period.

*Fighting hard, fighting on for the steel

Through the wastelands evermore

The scattered souls will feel the hell

Bodies wasted on the shores

On the blackest plains in hell’s domain

We watch them as they go

In fire and pain, now once again

We know*

Through the wastelands of capitalism, our revolutionaries choose to push on in their struggle, for they know it is just.

*So now, we fly ever free, we’re free before the thunderstorm

On towards the wilderness, our quest carries on

Far beyond the sundown, far beyond the moonlight

Deep inside our hearts and all our souls

So far away, we wait for the day

For the lives, all so wasted and gone

We feel the pain of a lifetime lost in a thousand days

Through the fire and the flames, we carry on*

The prechorus and chorus describes the soul of the revolutionary - their bodies may be engaged in a war against the capitalist hordes, but in their hearts, they are free, for they have class consciousness, solidarity, and are working to change their world.

*As the red day is dawning

And the lightning cracks the sky

They’ll raise their hands to the heavens above

With resentment in their eyes

Running back through the mid-morning light

There’s a burning in my heart

We’re banished from a time in a fallen land

To a life beyond the stars

In your darkest dreams, see to believe

Our destiny this time

And endlessly we’ll all be free

Tonight*

The “red day dawning” is quite obvious here. On a more literal level, this verse depicts the capitalist frustration - these revolutionaries had been exiled, but are now returning to establish the dictatorship of the proletariat. The capitalists are throwing up their hands in frustration as they are being beaten back. The communists know they will win, and are winning here.

*And on the wings of a dream, so far beyond reality

All alone in desperation, now the time has gone

Lost inside you’ll never find, lost within my own mind

Day after day, this misery must go on

Now, here we stand with their blood on our hands

We fought so hard now, can we understand?

I’ll break the seal of this curse if I possibly can

For freedom of every man*

While the revolutionaries did not want to engage in violent struggle, it was necessary for their revolution. They may have blood on their hands in a quite literal sense here, but they know that their revolution could not have succeeded peacefully. The final lyrics to the song reaffirm their commitment to fighting for the people.

This is dialectics.

17 points
*

Through the Fire and the Emblem is a song about a great turn based strategy series with usually dodgy politics.

permalink
report
reply

Nah it’s about communism check my other comment

permalink
report
parent
reply
12 points

(my comment was a shitpost, reread the sixth word in it)

permalink
report
parent
reply

Lmao I have the big dumb and was working on trying to format the lyrics (I just gave up, fuck it)

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

:comrade-edelgard:

permalink
report
parent
reply
15 points

This is exactly what I did when I was 13 and tried to prove that every band was actually Christian

I was right btw

permalink
report
reply

bit idea fedora athiest parents who think all rock music is secretly Christian and is indoctrinating their children

permalink
report
parent
reply
8 points

GOOD bit

permalink
report
parent
reply

Also don’t forget that all punk songs are actually about sandwiches.

permalink
report
parent
reply

Except for crust punk. That’s about pizza.

permalink
report
parent
reply

Fall of Efrafa songs are about pie

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

:sicko-yes:

permalink
report
parent
reply
10 points

TBH power metal seems like it would be hyperreactionary given how much they talk about glory and power but there are relatively few that take public political stances on anything, especially when compared to like black metal. Maybe it’s just too cheesy.

permalink
report
reply

Power metal is just dudes rocking about their D&D characters

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points
*

Except for Sabaton, which is dudes rocking about History Channel documentaries

Here they are covering a song that someone wrote as a style parody of them that has some fun reenactments of Nazis getting merced by the Red Army

oh and also Powerwolf which is dudes rocking about their VtM campaign

permalink
report
parent
reply

Iced Earth is dudes rocking out about anti-Semitic centralized banking conspiracies. And Spawn. But mostly the anti-Semitism thing.

permalink
report
parent
reply

Yeah, but fuck that guy. At least Hansi washed his hands of Demons and Wizards without a second thought; he’s almost certainly a :LIB: but he’s at least not an open Nazi like Schaefer.

permalink
report
parent
reply

I don’t actually listen to any power metal but TBH this song is a banger. I also fully realize that I’m probably in a small minority that never played Guitar Hero, and thus never burnt themselves out on it.

permalink
report
parent
reply
10 points
*

hey if we’re recommending power metal

I just think it’s neat

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

Rainbow absolutely counts - everything Dio ever did after “Carolina County Ball” counts in my book - and god I love Battle Beast with Nitte Valo. Good thing Beast in Black is out there.

permalink
report
parent
reply
10 points
*

ok well I’ll leave you some recommendations and you can check it out and see what you like

Power metal is basically built on three pillars that every band pulls from in one degree or another:

Play it fast and loud like Spread Your Fire by Angra

Big epic arrangements like Sacred Worlds by Blind Guardian

Sing about your D&D game in a continental European accent like Emerald Sword by Rhapsody

permalink
report
parent
reply
4 points

I fear that a lot of them are reactionary, and know of a couple who are: three members of Dragonforce used to be in a nazi band called Demoniac. The singer(?) from Iced Earth was at the Jan 6th riots (Iron Saviour’s social media told the band to stay out of Germany after this was revealed IIRC).

On another note, I read an interview once with Hansi from Blind Guardian where he said he suported Die Linke when asked about politics but didn’t really elaborate.

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

It was the guitarist from Iced Earth, and the powermetal subreddit were actually the ones that figured it out . I remember hearing about other 80s metal dudes who had that same strain of petty bourgeois Fox News brainworms, I think Tom Arroyo was like that too.

On the flip side there’s also A Sound of Thunder who support the Catalonian independence movement

permalink
report
parent
reply
9 points

:tequila-sunset: “The Man from Hjelmdall is communist”

permalink
report
reply

Fighting hard, fighting on for the steel

This is an obvious reference to :stalin-pipe:

permalink
report
reply

:nicholson-yes:

permalink
report
parent
reply